Every COP since 2018 has pulled the press towards climate. Antalya is the first to start on the industry's ground: the energy crisis. We followed seven summits in the international press and in the own channels of climate organisations and the oil and gas industry to see what is different this time, why it matters, and what the movement can do about it.
Four to two weeks before a COP, energy competes with climate for the headlines. Once the summit opens, climate rises at every COP but one and the energy-crisis frame falls at all of them: in Glasgow from 32% to 10%, in Sharm el-Sheikh from 42% to 22%. The coverage turns to what the summit is for: the targets (the Paris goals, net zero) and who is failing to meet them.
| COP | Climate frame | Energy-crisis frame | Renewables | Oil | False solutions |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Katowice 2018 | 58% → 71% | 35% → 23% | 7% → 4% | 29% → 19% | 45% → 41% |
| Madrid 2019 | 82% → 86% | 11% → 8% | 3% → 5% | 6% → 7% | 44% → 47% |
| Glasgow 2021 | 53% → 75% | 32% → 10% | 8% → 5% | 10% → 5% | 40% → 44% |
| Sharm el-Sheikh 2022 | 46% → 65% | 42% → 22% | 8% → 8% | 6% → 3% | 54% → 41% |
| Dubai 2023 | 56% → 58% | 23% → 9% | 7% → 7% | 17% → 6% | 39% → 40% |
| Baku 2024 | 53% → 54% | 20% → 16% | 17% → 13% | 4% → 8% | 45% → 38% |
| Belém 2025 | 48% → 36% | 23% → 12% | 12% → 13% | 6% → 0% | 34% → 37% |
| Antalya 2026 | 37% → ? | 52% → ? | 3% → ? | 20% → ? | 36% → ? |
Share of headlines, four to two weeks before → during each summit. Renewables and oil exclude oilprice.com. False solutions: hydrogen, CCS, gas/LNG and nuclear as a share of technology headlines (theirs plus renewables) in general news; Antalya rests on 22 headlines.
Climate has never started this low (37%; the previous minimum was 46%, before Sharm el-Sheikh) and the energy crisis never this high (52%; previous maximum 42%).
Share of headlines four to two weeks before each summit.
The vocabulary has changed with it. In the same weeks before Belém, the press talked about climate change, net zero, renewable energy and the energy transition; before Antalya, about oil and gas prices, the energy crisis and energy security.
Share of headlines with each phrase, 14 Sep–26 Oct. oilprice.com excluded.
Oil is back in the news, but as a market story: since June, only 24 of 1,052 oil headlines frame it at all; the rest report prices and supply. Among those that do, the industry took the lead in spring, with the conflict in the Middle East, for the first time since 2018 (+0.24 for 2026). Since June it is a tie, 12 to 12.
And the two sides arrive differently. Climate organisations are posting about people (40%), nature (31%) and extreme weather (14%); only 6% of their posts mention the summit, against 27% at the same point before Belém. The industry is posting about oil as a necessity (27%), innovation (27%) and emissions (20%).
Year by year, the more the press frames energy as a crisis, the more oil leans to the industry (R² = 0.82 across the nine years; 0.71 by quarter). 2026 carries much of it: without it, the link holds by quarter (r = 0.56) but is weak by year (R² = 0.33). The more climate there is in the coverage, the more oil is the movement's (−0.94).
Part of this link is built in: framing oil as a necessity often uses the language of energy security. But it is not automatic. In the second quarter of 2020, with the COVID oil-price collapse, 43% of headlines were about energy and the movement still defined oil (−0.77): energy talk without the security frame does not hand oil to the industry.
The movement did best in 2018 and 2019, the Fridays for Future years: oil was framed as the culprit almost every time (−0.96 and −0.94), climate was in 63–74% of headlines. Among the summits, Madrid 2019 and Dubai 2023: climate and accountability set the agenda, the energy frame stayed under 10% during the summit, and the movement defined oil by 49 to 0 and 45 to 2.
How each outlet's mix of frames resembles each side, 2025 against 2026 (resemblance to the industry minus resemblance to the movement; below zero = closer to the movement). No outlet with enough coverage moved towards the movement.
| The Guardian | −0.35 → −0.14 |
| Inside Climate News | −0.25 → −0.17 |
| Carbon Brief | −0.24 → −0.15 |
| The Conversation | −0.23 → −0.13 |
| Grist | −0.27 → −0.13 |
| Vox | −0.17 → −0.01 |
Climate-specialist outlets moved least.
| Al Jazeera | −0.45 → +0.14 |
| CNN | −0.19 → +0.30 |
| NBC News | −0.22 → +0.24 |
| South China Morning Post | −0.18 → +0.28 |
| The Independent | −0.26 → +0.19 |
| BBC | −0.27 → +0.17 |
| Fox News | −0.13 → +0.28 |
| CBS News | −0.09 → +0.31 |
| NPR | −0.24 → +0.15 |
| Sydney Morning Herald | −0.20 → +0.19 |
| Forbes | −0.06 → +0.30 |
| Deutsche Welle | −0.28 → +0.07 |
| Politico Europe | −0.11 → +0.17 |
| Time | −0.23 → +0.04 |
Broadcasters and international outlets moved most.
The mechanism is the same everywhere: the energy-crisis frame went from marginal to dominant. At CNN, from 11% to 83% of headlines between June–October 2025 and 2026; at Al Jazeera from 0% to 53%; at the BBC from 12% to 33%. At The Guardian the climate frame held (61% → 58%) while energy rose (2% → 26%).
Outlets with at least 15 headlines in both years. 2026 is January to 21 October.
Climate organisations do talk about solutions once a summit starts. Before Glasgow they offered one solution for every four problems in their posts; during the summit, two for every three (0.25 → 0.66). Sharm el-Sheikh: 0.34 → 0.84. Before Antalya they are at 0.15, about one for every seven, the lowest since Madrid 2019.
Dubai 2023: very few posts in the sample, off the scale.
This is what we call Frame Compensation: compare how short the movement falls on solutions on its own, and how short once the industry's frames are added. Across the nine years, the wider the movement's gap, the more the industry fills it in its own channels with hydrogen, CCS, gas and nuclear (correlation 0.60). In the years of the transition debate, 2021–2023, that reached the press: coverage of hydrogen and CCS followed the industry's posts (0.57 and 0.54), and the press framed them the industry's way (hydrogen +0.73 to +1.00, CCS +0.50 to +0.87).
In an energy crisis the industry does not need to compensate. It aligns problem and solution with its traditional portfolio: oil and gas as a necessity rise to 76% of its framed presence in the press in 2022 and 92% in 2026. It still posts about false solutions (21% of its posts in 2026), but general news carries the fewest of the series. What reaches the news is oil. That is the other peculiarity of Antalya: the industry has never needed false solutions less.
Industry-side frames in the press: oil and gas as a necessity, against CCS, hydrogen and nuclear as solutions. Right: share of headlines framing energy as a crisis, and the compensation rate (CR), which counts oil and gas as a necessity as part of the industry's solutions; that is why it reads high in 2022 and 2026.
We measured which of each side's frames rise and fall in the press with its own posts, month by month since 2018, and which mobilise its own audience. The movement's frames that travel fast ride on events and on people.
| Frame | Moves with the press (r, monthly changes) | Engagement on own channels (1 = average) | Reading |
|---|---|---|---|
| Paris goals · movement | 0.64 | 0.52 | Travels mostly with the summits (0.38 outside November–December) |
| Young people · movement | 0.43 | 1.40 | Travels all year and mobilises: the only frame that does both |
| Extreme weather · movement | 0.34 | 0.76 | Travels |
| Emissions, science, health · movement | 0.21–0.25 | 0.56–0.88 | Travel moderately |
| Renewables as a solution · movement | 0.10–0.25 | 0.51 | Little month to month; travels over the years (0.72) |
| Oil as the culprit · movement | 0.06 | 0.76 | Does not travel month to month; wins at summits |
| Energy crisis · industry | 0.17 | 0.89 | Leads the press by about three months in level (r = 0.50) |
| Gas as a solution · industry | 0.11 | 1.39 | Mobilises its audience; reaches the press only via the trade press |
Renewables work on a slower clock. When climate organisations post more about them, general news covers them more over the years (correlation 0.72), and the press frames them on the movement's side every year. Yet they take 2–12% of the movement's posts, less than the industry spends casting doubt on them (11–13% in 2021–2024). And the solutions conversation is shared ground: renewables and false solutions rise and fall together in the news (0.43, month to month).
| Renewables headlines in general news, 2018–2026 | Headlines | Framed as a solution | NDI | Also framed as an energy crisis |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| With a climate frame | 835 | 12% | −0.82 | — |
| For jobs, lower bills or sovereignty | 1,180 | 37% | −0.95 | 8% |
| · jobs and investment | 672 | 53% | −0.96 | 2% |
| · prices and bills | 447 | 17% | −0.92 | 15% |
| · sovereignty and security | 83 | 22% | −0.89 | 25% |
| Everything else | 21,462 | 8% | −0.65 | 2% |
Both framings work, and both are rare. Renewables with a climate frame: 835 headlines in eight years. Renewables for their benefits is the strongest framing renewables get, and it is growing (from 3–5% of renewables headlines in 2018–2024 to 11% in 2026), while barely feeding the crisis frame; sovereignty is the benefit closest to it. The advantage is not guaranteed: the press's balance on renewables has slipped from −0.78 in 2020 to −0.52 in 2025, and in general news they have stalled since 2021.
Antalya starts where no COP has started: on energy, with oil leaning to the industry, general news on its side and the movement without solutions. The evidence from seven summits points to three moves: the three of our Pre-COP brief in September, sharpened by the new data.
«On energy, the industry is winning. On climate, the movement still can: every COP since 2018 has proved it. But it has to arrive with solutions: an empty solution space does not stay empty.»Sílvia Díaz-Pérez, RELAT
RELAT measures who defines what a concept means in the press, week by week. We can follow these frames day by day through Antalya, for a concept, a country or a campaign message.
silvia@relat.cat · relat.cat · Pre-COP31 brief
Data. 64,333 English-language climate and energy headlines from 56 international outlets (GDELT), July 2018 to 26 October 2026. Own posts on X and Bluesky of major climate organisations and of oil and gas companies and associations, to 20 October 2026; the mix of accounts changed in 2026 and is thin in 2023. We compare shares, not volumes.
Windows. Each COP: four to two weeks before it opened (where Antalya stands today) and the summit days, Katowice 2018 to Belém 2025; no COP in 2020.
Method. Frames coded with RELAT's dictionary-based codebook, checked against independent human coding (κ = 0.73); it captures explicit frames and misses implicit ones, so energy sources are counted by keyword. NDI: balance between a concept's two poles, with 95% bootstrap intervals. Resemblance: cosine similarity of frame profiles by concept and role. «Solutions per problem»: solution frames over problem frames in each actor's posts. Frame Compensation (Díaz-Pérez 2025): imbalance rate IR = 1 / max-normalised prognosis share; CR = IR of the movement alone / IR of movement and industry combined; industry-side press frames are those where the press gives a concept the role the industry gives it. Technologies: a second set of 75,381 headlines from the same outlets that mention hydrogen, CCS, gas/LNG, nuclear or renewables, collected without the climate/energy seed phrases of the main corpus (which let few technology headlines in) and coded with the same codebook; rates per 10,000 headlines of those outlets, general news only; benefits of renewables identified by keyword. «Moves with the press»: correlation of month-to-month changes, 2018–2026; this measures co-movement, not causation. Small numbers for Antalya's window and for 2026 posts: read them as direction. Climate in 2026: our Pre-COP brief gave 26% of headlines for the year to mid-September; the 37% here is the two weeks before the summit; over 2026 to 21 October it is 27%. Same measure, different windows.